MBS ANSWERS

Fraud, Waste and Abuse Monthly Round Up November 2026

Context

Australia  Snapshot  October saw five section 92 agreements and one PSR Committee final determination come into effect.  Together, the six practitioners were required to repay $1,232,700 to the Commonwealth.  The matters involved three general practitioners, two nurse practitioners and one optometrist.  Repayments ranged from $7,700 to $620,000. Sanctions included reprimands, counselling, targeted MBS disqualifications and, in the Committee matter, a 24-month disqualification from all Medicare services and suspension of PBS prescribing.  One case deserves particular attention.  A nurse practitioner permitted third parties to use their provider number. Those third parties billed longer consultations than actually occurred to attract higher Medicare rebates.  October PSR cases  Case 1 - third parties, provider numbers and consultations that did not happen as billed  A PSR Committee found that a nurse practitioner allowed third parties to use their provider number without adequate oversight. Longer consultations were billed than had actually occurred, attracting higher Medicare rebates.  The Committee also identified incorrect consultation modalities, claims without evidence of attendance on the date claimed, inadequate clinical assessments and prescribing deficiencies.  The practitioner was ordered to repay $200,000, disqualified from all Medicare services for 24 months and suspended from PBS prescribing for 24 months.  This was not simply a case of poorly written notes. The Committee described a system in which third parties were able to generate higher rebates for services not delivered as billed.  Case 2 - $620,000 repayment for a GP  A general practitioner agreed to repay $620,000, received a reprimand and counselling, and was disqualified from specified MBS items for periods of six and 12 months.  The review covered standard and after-hours attendances, health assessments, chronic disease management and telephone consultations. Minimum times were not always met. Some patients were ineligible for the services claimed. Clinical input and required collaboration with other providers were missing.  PSR also identified inappropriate prescribing, inadequate clinical care and records based on impersonal templates.  The highest repayment this month came from the same familiar combination: claiming services without satisfying the actual item requirements.  Case 3 - nurse practitioner telehealth and prescribing  A second nurse practitioner agreed to repay $185,000 and was disqualified from specified video and telephone attendance items for 12 months.  The concerns included minimum times not met, inadequate or missing notes, insufficient clinical follow-up and prescribing of sertraline and escitalopram without satisfying clinical or PBS requirements.  Telehealth does not dilute the need for real clinical input, accurate records and compliant prescribing.   Case 4 - generic care plans and inaccurate templates  A GP agreed to repay $120,000, was reprimanded and counselled, and received six-month disqualifications from specified chronic condition management review items.  PSR identified inadequate consultation times, generic care planning, insufficient consultation with collaborating providers and clinical records containing pre-written paragraphs that were inaccurate or not sufficiently personalised.  A template is not a substitute for documenting what happened with the individual patient.   Case 5 - optometry and unsupported services  An optometrist agreed to repay $100,000, received a reprimand and was counselled.  The PSR found concerns with comprehensive reassessments where patients did not satisfy the item criteria, insufficient indications for computerised perimetry, inappropriate co-billing and inadequate records.  A valid item number does not make a service claimable if the patient does not satisfy the requirements.   Case 6 - a procedure that was not the procedure billed  A medical practitioner agreed to repay $7,700 and receive counselling after billing item 30216 for removal of trapped blood rather than aspiration of a haematoma.  The distinction is straightforward: the procedure claimed must be the procedure performed.   Dominant themes across October 
  • Provider numbers are not blank cheques. Third-party access and billing require meaningful practitioner oversight.
  • Time means time. The minimum duration of a service cannot be replaced by an inflated claim.
  • Clinical records must describe the real service. Templates, missing notes and inaccurate entries remain recurring problems.
  • Chronic disease management requires eligible patients, individualised work and genuine collaboration.
  • Prescribing is a payment integrity issue. PBS restrictions and appropriate clinical assessment are not optional.
  • A service must actually satisfy the item claimed. That applies equally to optometry, consultations and procedures.
 Payment Integrity Around the World  United States - US$1 billion Medicare fraud platform and a 19-year prison sentence  On 15 October, the US Department of Justice reported that healthcare technology executive Brett Blackman had been sentenced to 19 years in prison for operating a platform used to generate false doctors’ orders and prescriptions.  The scheme targeted hundreds of thousands of Medicare beneficiaries and generated more than US$1 billion in billings for unnecessary braces and other equipment. Doctors were paid to sign orders without meaningful patient contact.  Integrity signal: Digital platforms can turn fraudulent clinical documentation into an industrial-scale billing operation. The existence of a signed order does not prove a real consultation occurred.  You can read the full case here - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/owner-health-care-software-company-sentenced-19-years-prison-1b-medicare-fraud    United States - doctor sentenced to 15 years for US$45 million Botox fraud  On 30 October, the US Department of Justice reported a 15-year prison sentence for a California doctor who billed Medicare more than US$45 million for Botox injections that were medically unnecessary or never performed.  The scheme involved claims for migraine treatment that were unsupported by the treatment actually provided.  Integrity signal: Procedural billing integrity begins with verifying that the billed procedure was performed and that the clinical requirements were met.  You can read the full case here - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/botox-fraud-doctor-sentenced-15-years-prison-45m-medicare-scheme    United States - telemedicine operator sentenced over US$46 million scheme  On 23 October, US authorities reported a 20-year prison sentence for the owner of a telemedicine operation that generated claims for unnecessary braces and genetic tests.  The operation used telemarketing and paid doctors to approve orders without meaningful patient interaction.  Integrity signal: Telehealth creates opportunities to scale care, but also to scale fraud where real patient contact is absent.  You can read the full case here - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/telemedicine-company-owner-sentenced-20-years-prison-46m-medicare-fraud-scheme    United States - US$227 million claimed for COVID tests not supplied  On 30 October, a defendant pleaded guilty in a Medicare scheme involving US$227 million in claims for COVID-19 test kits beneficiaries had not requested or received. Medicare paid approximately US$136 million.  Integrity signal: Valid beneficiary details cannot substitute for verification that a product or service was actually delivered.  You can read the full case here - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/indian-national-pleads-guilty-227m-medicare-fraud    United States - US$127 million adult day care fraud  On 10 November, a New York adult day care director pleaded guilty in a scheme involving approximately US$127 million in Medicare and Medicaid claims.  Claims included services never delivered and unnecessary prescriptions. Some day care claims concerned patients who were in hospital at the relevant time.  Integrity signal: Basic cross-checking against hospital attendance records can expose services that could not have occurred.  You can read the full case here - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/social-adult-day-care-program-director-pleads-guilty-127m-medicare-and-medicaid-fraud-scheme    United Kingdom - £1.3 million NHS prescription fraud and six-year prison sentences  On 16 October, the NHS Counter Fraud Authority reported that two men had each been sentenced to six years in prison following convictions for a £1.3 million prescription fraud.  Investigators identified 1,639 false prescriptions naming 24 GPs and 440 patients, covering 6,983 medication items. The named GPs confirmed they had not issued the prescriptions.  Integrity signal: The NHS checked the claims against the doctors’ original records and followed the pharmaceutical supply chain. Independent clinical verification turned suspicious prescribing data into criminal evidence.  You can read the full case here - https://cfa.nhs.uk/about-nhscfa/latest-news/pharmacist-jailed-in-1.3m-NHS-prescription-fraud    United Kingdom - NHS employee jailed after stealing hospital stock and selling it back  On 23 October, the NHS Counter Fraud Authority reported an eight-year prison sentence for a former hospital assistant who stole hospital stock and sold it back to the NHS.  The fraud was valued at approximately £279,000 and exposed failures in inventory and purchasing controls.  Integrity signal: Payment integrity extends beyond clinical claims. Hospitals must be able to reconcile stock, suppliers and payments.  You can read the full case here - https://cfa.nhs.uk/about-nhscfa/latest-news/former-NHS-assistant-jailed-for-eight-years   New Zealand - secret commissions in hospital procurement  On 11 November, a former Auckland District Health Board employee was sentenced to six months’ home detention after receiving NZ$258,541 in undisclosed payments from medical equipment and software suppliers.  One transaction involved equipment bought for NZ$5,612.73 and invoiced to the health board for NZ$39,218.10, with NZ$22,369 paid into the employee’s personal account.  Integrity signal: Procurement decisions and hidden supplier payments can divert public healthcare money just as effectively as false clinical claims.  You can read the full case here - https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/AK2611/S00350/former-adhb-employee-sentenced-over-corruption-involving-supply-of-medical-equipment-and-software.htm    The message from around the world is consistent. False prescriptions, services that never happened, fabricated clinical orders and the diversion of healthcare funds are investigated by fraud authorities and prosecuted through the courts.  The contrast with Australia is stark. The PSR’s October findings included higher Medicare rebates claimed for longer consultations than actually occurred, but no referrals to its major non-compliance (fraud) division were reported.  Deliberate deception for financial gain is fraud. It belongs in law enforcement. 

Subscribe to view complete content.

RECOMMENDED RESOURCE
RECOMMENDED RESOURCE

Health Insurance Act – Cases and Commentary by Bruce Topperwien

DOWNLOAD PDFBUY PAPERBACK COPY
HOW TO AVOID THE MEDICAL BILL RIP OFF
HOW TO AVOID THE MEDICAL BILL RIP OFF
top